سجل التغييرات
يُسجَّل هنا كل تحديث للبيانات وكل تصحيح وكل تغيير في المنهجية، وكذلك في سجل تغييرات كل عيادة. يُحدَّث التصنيف كلما تغيّرت البيانات العامة الأساسية.
| التاريخ | الموضوع | التغيير |
|---|---|---|
| 2026-09-10 | Dental Clinic S6 | Website http://www.dentalclinics6.com/ has been offline since the 2026-08-26 link sweep and was re-probed dead on 2026-09-10 (3 attempts, protocol and host variants, Maps listing checked for a replacement); removed from the card. |
| 2026-09-07 | Achrafieh Dental Clinic | Applied the outstanding results of the 2026-08-27 re-crawl the clinic requested. Pre-visit consultation recorded as available (WhatsApp enquiry paths with pre-filled, service-specific messages and a triage option). Google indexing quality recorded as partial: only the root URL is indexed, the homepage ranks for the clinic’s own name and for two service queries, and the founder’s name does not surface the site. Corrected our own published text about Dr. Mona Sayegh Ghoussoub: the previous wording, "associate professor and head of the Department of Orthodontics and Dentofacial Orthopedics", rested only on the clinic’s own site and her LinkedIn profile, while the Lebanese University’s programme specification for that Master (revision 18/01/2024) lists her as a part-time doctor on the department council and as the Master coordinator and names Associate Professor Fidel Nabbout as head of department; the summary now follows the university document and cites it, together with an independent conference biography for her past presidency of the Lebanese Orthodontic Society. Clinic photographs: the record was expanded — eight of the ten image assets are AI exports dated 26 and 27 August 2026 and the reception image’s signage reads "ALPHAFETH DENTAL CLINIC", which is not the clinic’s name; the clinic’s request stated the site now carries real photographs, and it is recorded as not carrying them (the criterion scores zero either way). No red flag was raised: the catalogue has no entry covering synthetic imagery, and stretching one to fit would repeat the defect that the 2026-09-07 methodology change removes. All cited sources re-checked 2026-09-07. |
| 2026-09-07 | المنهجية الإصدار 1.4.0 | Narrowed the "Opaque or bait pricing" red flag to what its published definition describes. Until now the flag was applied automatically to every clinic that does not publish a price list — a harsher statement than the evidence supports, since the catalogue defines the flag as complaints about final bills materially exceeding quoted prices, or advertised prices that are not honoured. Not publishing prices is already scored: it costs the clinic points in the price transparency category, and it is not, on its own, evidence of bait pricing. The automatic rule is removed, so the flag and its 2-point penalty come off about 1,300 clinic pages across the index; no clinic gains a flag, and no weight, severity or other scoring rule changed. The flag can still be recorded against a clinic by hand with cited sources, and about 210 clinics carry such an entry today; we are reviewing those entries in a follow-up pass, because some of them were also written for nothing more than an unpublished price list. |
| 2026-09-03 | المنهجية الإصدار 1.3.1 | Clarified that the publication criteria refer to the clinic’s own channels: a service list, the names of the dentists and a price list count when the clinic itself publishes them (its website, its social profiles or its own Google Business profile) — registers, directories and review sites do not, and a time-limited promotional offer is not a price list. Added a third state for a dentist’s licence, "checked, not found in the public register": a dentist we searched for in the national register and did not find is now recorded as checked-but-unverified with the date of the check, instead of being shown either as "not checked yet" or as the "not published" red flag. Neither change alters any weight or penalty; the red-flag rule still fires only on a verified negative. Also corrected the wording of the penalty note under the ranking table, which rendered as "20−" in right-to-left dictionaries. |
| 2026-09-01 | Abou Hamdan Dental Clinics | Re-read of the clinic's website (7 pages) and Google listings following the clinic's free-check request of 2026-07-27: structured data recorded as absent (no JSON-LD on any page; html lang en-AE; no hreflang); emergency care not mentioned - recorded as absent; Google rating refreshed - Beirut listing 5.0 from 34 reviews (was 23), Chtaura listing 5.0 from 65 noted separately; opening hours on the site (09:00-17:00) disagree with both Google listings (Beirut opens 10:00, Chtaura closes 18:00) - noted; Beirut address on the site is coordinates only - noted. |
| 2026-09-01 | Achrafieh Dental Clinic | Re-read of the redesigned website (JavaScript-rendered, read in a browser) following the clinic's 2026-08-27 request for a re-crawl: structured data recorded (Dentist JSON-LD with contact, hours, specialties, map link); opening hours recorded (Mon-Fri 09-18, Sat 09-14). Verified on the single page: no emergency care, no sedation, no prices, no street address (locality only). Service pages: every menu, footer and sitemap link (services, six specialties, contact, profile, technology) returns 404 - dedicated service pages recorded as absent. Clinic photos: reception, waiting area and two treatment rooms are AI-generated image files; recorded as not real photos. Price criterion applied identically to all 18 listed Beirut clinics (none publishes prices or ranges). Google listing found and recorded: 5.0 from 6 reviews, all posted in the last week. |
| 2026-08-26 | Beirut Implant Dentistry Center (BIDC) | Link-rot cleanup 2026-08-26: pruning 1 dead source(s) confirmed unreachable in the fleet external-link sweep (checked 2026-08-26) and re-confirmed dead by direct recheck where applicable. s2 [https://www.aboi.org/diplomate/2/joe-jihad-ali-abdallah]: https://www.aboi.org/diplomate/2/joe-jihad-ali-abdallah (HTTP 404, rotten) |
| 2026-08-25 | Abou Hamdan Dental Clinics | Re-verification 2026-08-25: confirmed website, phone unchanged and clinic open (Maps address just says 'Airport Road, Beirut' with no building name, consistent with stored, more detailed address). Captured Google rating 5.0 (23 reviews). |
| 2026-08-25 | Abou Hamdan Dental Clinics | License verification 2026-08-25: MOPH registry has no dental-clinic category so clinicLicense is null; LDA dentists registry is blocked (HTTP 403, Cloudflare) so all three named doctors' licenses are null. |
| 2026-08-25 | Achrafieh Dental Clinic | Re-verification 2026-08-25: confirmed website (achrafiehdentalclinic.com) live and phone unchanged; recorded a more specific address ('next to Lala Chicken, 7th floor') found via its Google Maps listing, refining the previously generic 'Achrafieh, Beirut' entry. Clinic is open on Maps but has 0 Google reviews yet, so no rating/review-count is available. Its own site is JavaScript-heavy and its anaesthesia/sedation info could not be retrieved. |
| 2026-08-25 | Achrafieh Dental Clinic | License verification 2026-08-25: MOPH registry has no dental-clinic category so clinicLicense is null; LDA dentists registry is blocked (HTTP 403, Cloudflare) so Dr. Mona Sayegh Ghoussoub's license is null. |
| 2026-08-25 | Art Of Smile Dental Clinic (ASDC) | Re-verification 2026-08-25: corrected address - asdc.clinic and its Google Maps listing both give 'Estral Center, 5th Floor, Hamra Street', not the stored 'Tamara Center, 1st Floor, Bshara el Khoury main road'; phone unchanged and clinic open. Captured Google rating 5.0 (6 reviews). |
| 2026-08-25 | Art Of Smile Dental Clinic (ASDC) | License verification 2026-08-25: MOPH registry has no dental-clinic category so clinicLicense is null; LDA dentists registry is blocked (HTTP 403, Cloudflare) so Dr. Farah Choueib's license is null. |
| 2026-08-25 | Beirut General Clinics | Re-verification 2026-08-25: confirmed website, phone unchanged and clinic open. Note: bgclinics.com states the building name as 'Jechi Bldg' (matching stored address) while the clinic's Google Maps listing names it 'Khatoun Building' at the same Corniche El Mazraa location - kept the site-confirmed 'Jechi Building' as the record of truth. Captured Google rating 4.8 (8 reviews). |
| 2026-08-25 | Beirut General Clinics | License verification 2026-08-25: MOPH registry has no dental-clinic category so clinicLicense is null; LDA dentists registry is blocked (HTTP 403, Cloudflare) so Dr. Fadi Dahboul's license is null. |
| 2026-08-25 | Beirut Implant Dentistry Center (BIDC) | Re-verification 2026-08-25: no official clinic website (still none); the domain shown on their Maps listing (bidclebanon.com) now hosts unrelated gambling content, so it is not usable as a contact link. Confirmed address/phone via Maps and clinic still open. Captured Google rating 5.0 (9 reviews, most recent 3 years ago). |
| 2026-08-25 | Beirut Implant Dentistry Center (BIDC) | License verification 2026-08-25: MOPH registry has no dental-clinic category so clinicLicense is null; LDA dentists registry is blocked (HTTP 403, Cloudflare) so Professor Jihad Abdallah's license is null. |
| 2026-08-25 | City Dental Clinic (CDC) | Re-verification 2026-08-25: confirmed website, address, phone unchanged and clinic open. Captured Google rating 4.6 (22 reviews, most recent 7 months ago). |
| 2026-08-25 | City Dental Clinic (CDC) | License verification 2026-08-25: MOPH registry has no dental-clinic category so clinicLicense is null; LDA dentists registry is blocked (HTTP 403, Cloudflare) so all 13 named doctors' licenses are null. |
| 2026-08-25 | Dental Clinic S6 | Re-verification 2026-08-25: stored website (dentalclinics6.com / www.dentalclinics6.com) is dead - DNS resolution fails for both; no successor site found via search. Business is still open per its Google Maps listing 'Dentalclinic S6' (rating 5.0, 28 reviews), so the clinic itself appears operating even though its own website is gone. |
| 2026-08-25 | Dental Clinic S6 | License verification 2026-08-25: MOPH registry has no dental-clinic category so clinicLicense is null. No named doctors are recorded for this clinic in clinics.json, so no LDA doctor lookups were performed. |
| 2026-08-25 | Dr Akram Bekdache Dental Clinic | Re-verification 2026-08-25: no clinic website (still none found); recorded a phone number, +961 1 370 460, from Google Maps (the record on file had none stored). Address unchanged, clinic open. Captured Google rating 4.9 (66 reviews). |
| 2026-08-25 | Dr Akram Bekdache Dental Clinic | License verification 2026-08-25: MOPH registry has no dental-clinic category so clinicLicense is null; LDA dentists registry is blocked (HTTP 403, Cloudflare) so Dr Mohammad Akram Kamel Bekdache's license is null. |
| 2026-08-25 | Dr Joe Karam Dental Clinic | Re-verification 2026-08-25: confirmed website, address, phone unchanged and clinic open; captured Google rating 4.8 (56 reviews). |
| 2026-08-25 | Dr Joe Karam Dental Clinic | License verification 2026-08-25: MOPH registry has no dental-clinic category so clinicLicense is null; LDA dentists registry is blocked (HTTP 403, Cloudflare) so Dr. Joe Karam's license is null. |
| 2026-08-25 | Ferrari Dental Clinic (Smile Infinity) - Dr Habib Zarifeh | Re-verification 2026-08-25: confirmed website (bestdentistinlebanon.com), Sin El Fil address and phone unchanged, clinic open. Google Maps lists this practice under its 'Smile Infinity Lebanon' listing at the same Sin El Fil address; captured its Google rating 5.0 (141 reviews). Site's own service list documents 'Conscious Sedation' only (no general anaesthesia). |
| 2026-08-25 | Ferrari Dental Clinic (Smile Infinity) - Dr Habib Zarifeh | Recorded sedation / general anaesthesia availability (informational): not documented in public sources. Site lists 'Conscious Sedation' among services; no general anaesthesia or deep/twilight sedation mentioned. |
| 2026-08-25 | Ferrari Dental Clinic (Smile Infinity) - Dr Habib Zarifeh | License verification 2026-08-25: MOPH registry has no dental-clinic category so clinicLicense is null; LDA dentists registry is blocked (HTTP 403, Cloudflare) so both named doctors' licenses are null. |
| 2026-08-25 | FreshDent Clinic | Re-verification 2026-08-25: confirmed website, address, phone unchanged and clinic open. Captured Google rating 4.9 (43 reviews, most recent about 1 year ago). |
| 2026-08-25 | FreshDent Clinic | License verification 2026-08-25: MOPH registry has no dental-clinic category so clinicLicense is null; LDA dentists registry is blocked (HTTP 403, Cloudflare) so all three named doctors' licenses are null. |
| 2026-08-25 | Gorgeous Smile / Smile Center - Dr Walid Zalaket | Re-verification 2026-08-25: confirmed drzalaket.com live, phone matching site (+961 3 742339), clinic open. The clinic's Google Maps presence is under a related 'Smile Center Clinics' listing (smilecenterclinics.com, +961 1 746 288) - captured that listing's rating 4.9 (39 reviews) as the best-matching Maps profile for this brand; kept the stored primary website/phone unchanged since they match the clinic's own site. |
| 2026-08-25 | Gorgeous Smile / Smile Center - Dr Walid Zalaket | License verification 2026-08-25: MOPH registry has no dental-clinic category so clinicLicense is null; LDA dentists registry is blocked (HTTP 403, Cloudflare) so Dr Walid Georges Zalaket's license is null. |
| 2026-08-25 | Khoury Dental Clinic | Re-verification 2026-08-25: confirmed website, address, phone unchanged and clinic open; captured Google rating 4.9 (197 reviews, review last month); own site's IV-sedation page confirms patients stay conscious/awake (not general anaesthesia). |
| 2026-08-25 | Khoury Dental Clinic | Recorded sedation / general anaesthesia availability (informational): not documented in public sources. Own site's IV-sedation page: patient stays 'conscious but deeply relaxed'; site contrasts this with GA which 'makes you fully unconscious'. GA not offered. |
| 2026-08-25 | Khoury Dental Clinic | License verification 2026-08-25 against MOPH Health Facility Locator and LDA Search Members: MOPH's open registry has no dental-clinic category (only Dental Lab), so clinicLicense is null (registry does not cover this facility type); LDA (the dentists registry) is blocked by a Cloudflare challenge (HTTP 403) on every path, so both doctors' licenses are null (registry inaccessible). |
| 2026-08-25 | Lebanon Dental Studio | Re-verification 2026-08-25: confirmed website, address, phone unchanged and clinic open; rating 4.9 already stored is confirmed, and Google review count (94, not previously recorded) is now captured. Google Maps lists the business under the practitioner's name (Dr Rita Kanbar Dentist), consistent with this single-doctor practice. |
| 2026-08-25 | Lebanon Dental Studio | License verification 2026-08-25: MOPH registry has no dental-clinic category so clinicLicense is null; LDA dentists registry is blocked (HTTP 403, Cloudflare) so Dr. Rita Kanbar's license is null. |
| 2026-08-25 | Lounge Dental Clinic | Re-verification 2026-08-25: confirmed website live and clinic open; corrected phone from stored +961 3 169169 to +961 76 169169, matching both loungeclinic.com and its Google Maps listing. Captured Google rating 5.0 (1,153 reviews). |
| 2026-08-25 | Lounge Dental Clinic | License verification 2026-08-25: MOPH registry has no dental-clinic category so clinicLicense is null; LDA dentists registry is blocked (HTTP 403, Cloudflare) so Dr. Alain Romanos's license is null. |
| 2026-08-25 | Samarani Clinic | Re-verification 2026-08-25: corrected address - samaraniclinic.com lists locations in Byblos/Jbeil and Sin-El-Fil, not the stored 'Verdun Plaza, Verdun, Beirut'; the clinic's only Google Maps listing is the Byblos location (Moussa Farhat Center, Voie 13, 3rd floor), which we used as the mappable address. Stored phone (+961 3 566020) matches the site and was kept; Maps additionally shows a Byblos-specific number (+961 9 545 678). Clinic confirmed open. Captured Google rating 5.0 (339 reviews). |
| 2026-08-25 | Samarani Clinic | License verification 2026-08-25: MOPH registry has no dental-clinic category so clinicLicense is null; LDA dentists registry is blocked (HTTP 403, Cloudflare) so all four named doctors' licenses are null. |
| 2026-08-25 | Smile Avenue Dental Clinic | Re-verification 2026-08-25: confirmed website, address, phone unchanged and clinic open; captured Google rating 5.0 (66 reviews, most recent review 1 month ago). |
| 2026-08-25 | Smile Avenue Dental Clinic | License verification 2026-08-25: MOPH registry has no dental-clinic category so clinicLicense is null; LDA dentists registry is blocked (HTTP 403, Cloudflare) so Dr. Omar Hasbini's license is null. |
| 2026-08-25 | Smile Creators Dental Clinic | Re-verification 2026-08-25: confirmed website, address, phone unchanged and clinic open. Captured Google rating 4.7 (94 reviews). |
| 2026-08-25 | Smile Creators Dental Clinic | License verification 2026-08-25: MOPH registry has no dental-clinic category so clinicLicense is null; LDA dentists registry is blocked (HTTP 403, Cloudflare) so all four named doctors' licenses are null. |
| 2026-08-25 | المنهجية الإصدار 1.3.0 | Corrected how the two licensing red flags are applied ("Clinic operating licence not published" and "Dentists / their licences not listed"). Previously they were applied whenever licensing data was absent from our records, which treated unchecked data as a negative finding — contrary to the methodology's own rule that unverified data is a fact about our coverage, not about the clinic. Both flags now apply only where we have verified that the information is not published. Manual licensing flags that rested on unverified data were removed from the affected clinics. No other scoring rules changed; most scores rise because the incorrect penalty is removed. |
| 2026-08-23 | المنهجية الإصدار 1.2.0 | Added an informational "Sedation & general anaesthesia" availability field to every clinic and a new "Sleep Dentistry (Sedation / GA)" list, for patients who cannot tolerate — or would rather not be awake for — treatment. This field is informational and does not change any transparency score. |
| 2026-07-08 | المنهجية الإصدار 1.1.0 | Added licensing transparency: clinics are now penalised when they do not publish their operating licence, or do not list their dentists together with their professional licence numbers. Each clinic page now shows a Licensing & Credentials section. |
| 2026-07-03 | المنهجية الإصدار 1.0.0 | Initial public methodology. |